The Smith & Wesson Model 19 is the classic, mid-size .357 Magnum that set the standard for many years. The new 19 is based on an enhanced, improved round-butt K-frame that is stronger than the original design. The 4-inch barrel has the same profile as the old guns but is sleeved with a steel barrel. Instead of an ejection rod detent, the new gun has a frame-mounted detent for positive lock-up. The hammer, trigger and specific internal parts are manufactured using metal injection molding (MIM) but retain that classic look and feel. Unlike the older guns, the Classic model features a frame-mounted firing pin. The action on the Classic 19 is pure Smith & Wesson that is smooth with no grit or stacking. Smith has reproduced the original “Micro” style, adjustable rear sight and the red ramp insert in the front sight. All of the shooters noticed how shallow the rear sight notch was. This resulted in low scores in that category.
Grips are similar to the old Coke-bottle grips but are thinner. It was also nice to see a blued steel gun at a time when most manufacturers are just doing stainless steel. The Model 19 scored high in aesthetics, ergonomics, trigger control and accuracy. As with the Colt, the grips felt too thin, especially at the top of the grip, which affected comfort and recoil control with magnum loads. There was also a sharp edge at the top of the left grip. This, and the lighter weight, resulted in lower scores in recoil control. Still, the shooters felt that Smith did an exceptional job on the 19 Classic, rating it high in aesthetics, ergonomics and trigger control. Shooters also felt that, with an MSRP of $843, the Smith rated a 4.25 in the value/price point category.
Advertisement — Continue Reading Below
