Lipsey’s Smith & Wesson Model 686 Plus Mountain Gun

RevolversCenterfire RevolversLipsey’s Smith & Wesson Model 686 Plus Mountain Gun

Our Review Score

4.57

Public Score

0 out of 5

Our Overall Scores

5
/5

― Value

5
/5

― Reliability

4
/5

― Accuracy

4
/5

― Trigger

5
/5

― Ergonomics

5
/5

― Recoil

4
/5

― Concealment

In 1998 Smith & Wesson added an L-frame .357 Magnum to their Mountain Gun revolver series. It was based on the Model 686 Plus platform, which has a 7-shot cylinder. Like the other Mountain Guns, instead of a full-length barrel underlug, it had a tapered, half-lug 4-inch barrel, and was only produced for one year. At the 2025 SHOT Show Lipsey’s re-introduced the Smith & Wesson Model 686 Plus Mountain Gun as one of their Exclusives. 

The new .357 Magnum Mountain Gun differs from the original by having a 4.25” barrel, a pinned patridge front sight with a gold bead, the forward cylinder locking point on the yoke/crane, a reinforced forcing cone, bevels on the front edges of the cylinder, flash-chromed trigger, and hammer, plus Tyler Gun Works walnut Bear Hug grips. It weighs less than the standard Model 686 at 35 oz., and the overall length is 8.01-inches. 

Advertisement — Continue Reading Below

T&E was done on the new Lipsey’s offering with three different .357 Magnum loads and two different .38 Special loads. The best group, shooting from the bench, single action, at 15 yards measured 1.43-inches. Two 21-round practical shooting exercises were also run with the 686 Plus Mountain Gun using first .38 Special, then .357 Magnum ammunition. During the entire T&E there were no issues or malfunctions during the shooting of some 167 rounds of .38/.357 ammunition.

Our Overall Scores

5
/5

― Value

5
/5

― Reliability

4
/5

― Accuracy

4
/5

― Trigger

5
/5

― Ergonomics

5
/5

― Recoil

4
/5

― Concealment

Public Reviews (0)

This product has no reviews yet, be the first to change that!

Review This Product

All reviews are screened and approved by a human for fairness and accuracy.

Latest Reviews

Related Reviews

Taurus GX2 T.O.R.O.

The Taurus GX2 T.O.R.O. is an entry level, sub-compact 9mm that punches well above its weight class. Retailing for around $250, this optics ready,...

Bond Arms Dead Man’s Hand

In tribute to James Butler “Wild Bill” Hickok, premier gunfighter, Civil War spy and scout, lawman, gambler, showman, and a legend in his in...

Heritage Manufacturing Rough Rider .32 H&R

Heritage Manufacturing has been making the Rough Rider SA sixgun since 1993. In 2005, they produced a new version in .32 H&R Magnum in...